I am a die-hard tubing mascara fan since most mascara runs or flakes on me. This one is no different. I bought it because of the serum aspect (but was hoping it wouldn’t run). I like the idea of serum built into mascara. When I use this, my lashes do look nice, and I feel like I am doing something good for them. I do not see an overall improvement in them, but I probably don’t use it enough to tell. 

I don’t understand all the glowing reviews over this mascara because I think it is merely ok. It applies well, but it doesn’t lengthen or thicken very well. Perhaps it is just my lashes that are not co-operating? I don’t know.

I liked the creaminess of it, it went on smooth with no clumps and I felt that it was healthier for my lashes than most mascara,  but unless you already have thick and long lashes that are just light in color, it seemed to do little to enhance my lashes, it just really only applied color. 

The quality is great, does not thicken in a wand as other mascaras. My lashes are strong and very long due to this mascara.

I've been using this mascara consistently for over a year after getting my lash extensions removed, and I can honestly say it is the only mascara I have ever used that the "growth boosting" effects have actually been real. I also love the brush size because it adds volume! Background info- when I was a kid I would pull out my eyelashes and it continued through college due to stress. I have always had sparse, thin, blonde eyelashes and eyebrows, so once I damaged them it was VERY difficult to grow back. I thought they never would because I tried for so many years. The lash extensions actually helped them grow fuller, but when they were removed they were soooo short. I used a light coat of this mascara daily in combination with the neuLASH serum at night, and it's a miracle worker. I wish I had before and after pictures to share! Highly recommend getting the subscription if you want a mascara that makes your lashes look good and is also benefitting them at the same time. This brand just needs to create a growth-booster brow gel!!!

Black mascara- I haven't tried the brown one, so I can't speak to the way that one looks. But, the black version is very nice! My lashes are more moisturized after using it, and it gives a nice definition

This mascara volumizes, lengthens, and separates. It also helps your lashes to grow with continued use. Doesn't flake or dry out too fast. Love this!

I am hooked on this product. I have tried MANY mascaras and this is the only one the works for me. The serum helps repair my lashes while providing great length. No clumping.