I have gone through so many liquid eyeliners over many, many years, but the formulas keep changing so I had to find a new liner that worked for me. I had zero expectations but I love the soft brush on this liquid liner, it has a great pointed shape, the bristles are even, and it glides on the eyelid nicely. The not great part is that the liner seems slightly watery, so I find that I need to apply two coats to get a fully opaque black line. I also make sure to fully dry the liner but no matter what, after an hour, I always have black smudges. I don't think I've found my holy grail liner, but overall I'm satisfied with the product and am glad I tried it out.

this is the best black eyeliner I've found yet. didn't realize what inferior products I was using in the past until I tried this one. I plan to routinely purchase this from Dermstore because the product is fresh .

I applied sunblock, then applied this eyeliner. I took an hour long hot yoga class and went to work, outside, for a ten hour shift as a ski patroller. This eyeliner didn't budge. It applies smoothly with a very fine tip that guarantees accuracy. I'll never buy anything else.

This is hands down the best liquid liner I've ever used. It has the finest point, and once it's on, it doesn't budge. I only wish it came in more colors.

It's a decent black liquid eyeliner. Goes on smoothly on the eye lids , doesn't smudge

This is a great basic black liquid eyeliner! No issues with it staying on or smearing.

This draws the best cat eyes because of the fine tip but I have oily lids and quickly end up with raccoon eyes! This is not waterproof either as described. Unfortunate because the tip is so nice. It smudges after a couple of hours so it was a waste for me.

I have been using this eyeliner for over a year now and recently bought another brand of eyeliner. This only comes in black and I wanted to try another color hence the purchase from another brand. Already regretting that because this eyeliner is so easy to use and you don't need ninja-like skills to get a perfect wing. Buying this again, my only wish this came in different colors!

I'm so glad I found this. This eyeliner dries fast and it has great staying power. It lasted all day until I removed it.

the color is very black and it stays on your eyes for a good amount of time. recommend.