Pre-pandemic, I wore this all the time. After a year+ of never going out (and never using all of the last tube), I had to throw it away for eye health purposes. I tried replacing it with a Loreal cheapie mascara, which looked bad and ended up under my eyes. Now that things have opened up again, I decided it was time to buy good mascara again. This is my favorite. It adds volume, does not clump, stays put, and comes off fairly easily. I think Dermstore only sells Extreme Black. That's the color I've always used and I don't think it looks overly dramatic - just like I have long, thick lashes. For reference, I am pale with freckles and brown hair.

I love Estée Lauder and use the products everyday. This mascara is so lovely and gives a dramatic effect.

this mascara is so nice, I love how black it is and how it lengthens my lashes. it def volumnizes them! highly recommend.

I've been a fan of Estee Lauder's Sumptuous Knockout Defining Lift and Fan Mascara for a while, but since Dermstore doesn't sell that one I thought I'd try this one instead. It was horrible! I sent it back. It's so clumpy and did nothing to lift or lengthen my lashs.

Gives lashes a boost of volume and length. This used to be my go-to mascara for big bold lashes. I have since switched to a different brand with clean ingredients.

I have trouble with mascaras because they don't hold a curl. This one doesn't do much for the lashes.

Just got it, and I like it, It doesn't flake or smudge. It comes off easily with facial towelettes. I rarely buy the same cosmetic products twice and this is a one time product for me , but it is good enough to try it.

This is a nice mascara. Easy to apply. Easy to remove. I have repurchased this product.

I really enjoy the wand and formula of this mascara. It adds a ton of volume and it keeps my lashes up throughout the day.

Whenever I use this mascara, I don't need to curl my eyelashes beforehand. It makes my lashes look very full and dark.