Rewards members get DOUBLE points on our Most-Wanted brands. START EARNING

jane iredale Eye Pencil (0.04 oz.)

Customer Reviews

jane iredale Eye Pencil (0.04 oz.) Customer Reviews

USD 20.0

$20.00

jane iredale Eye Pencil (0.04 oz.)
Overall Rating : 4.57 / 5 (67 Reviews)
  • 51 5 star reviews
  • 7 4 star reviews
  • 7 3 star reviews
  • 0 2 star reviews
  • 2 1 star reviews
4.57 / 5 (67 Reviews)
  • 51 5 star reviews
  • 7 4 star reviews
  • 7 3 star reviews
  • 0 2 star reviews
  • 2 1 star reviews

Where reviews refer to beauty products or supplements, results may vary from person to person. Customer reviews are independent and do not represent the views of Dermstore.

Reward members earn 50 points for every review written on verified purchases.

I love this eye pencil!

5

This is my go to eye pencil! It is easy to apply and stays on all day. I just love it.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

very pleased

5

I was looking for some definition but not too drastic on "mature" eyes. I am very pleased with this product. It goes on easily without pulling or tugging, and I have found it to wear well. I have already purchased a second color, the midnight blue which I love, and I am looking at a third.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (1) No (0)
Report this review

Nice pencil, one big concern

5

I really liked this pencil. Creamy and easy to apply and lasted throughout the day. It was also easy to remove. I purchased the brown-black. However, after using this pencil for approximately 7 weeks, I wanted to sharpen it. I used my eyeliner sharpener but was left with a splintered mess and now the product is unusable. I went on line to read if other reviewers had a similar problem, and that is when I noticed that Jane Iredale has her own sharpener and that is what is recommended for this pencil. ( I did not find the Iredale sharpener on the dermstore website, so will have to look elsewhere.) I just wanted to alert others that they should not use another type of sharpener for this pencil. I really liked the pencil, but am disappointed to have to purchase a separate sharpener. I was annoyed to find this out after trying to sharpen it and was left with a splintered unusable mess.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (2) No (0)
Report this review

a true black eye pencil

4

It's hard to find an eye pencil that's a true black color and doesn't require a lot of rubbing to remove. This liner does sometimes smudge during the day if you're not careful, but the upside is that it's quite easy to remove at the end of the day.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Perfect for a natural look.

5

Anyone can wear this taupe color. It gives a little something extra to your eyes that is not too noticeable, just enough to make you look finished. It goes on well with no smear or any problem like a dry pencil would do...it's just smooth enough. It stays on all day, even when my eyes tear up.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Replaced my #7

5

Great pencil, creamy, long lasting pencil. Goes on easily. Ordered the brown/black.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (3) No (2)
Report this review

Great eye pencil

5

Love that I know that I am using an eye pencil that has clean ingredients. I use the black/grey and the color looks great with my dark eyes. I goes on smoothly and stay put all day long.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

The best pencil

5

Great eye pencil. It helps with that smoky eye for the mature woman. Easy to remove as well after a long day at work. I love this pencil

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

My favorite liner

5

This eyeliner goes on smoothly without pulling. Love the color options with combo variations. Stays on well.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Very Creamy

5

I love everything Jane Iredale. This eye pencil does not disappoint. Very creamy, pigmented and smooth. It does not smear on me and is long lasting.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

jane iredale Eye Pencil (0.04 oz.) Customer Reviews

USD 20.0

$20.00

jane iredale Eye Pencil (0.04 oz.)

Quantity

( 0 item in your basket items in your basket )