It's fine for something discrete but I can't use it for any dramatic looks.

This is a repeat purchase for me. It doesnt run, gives a really dark black line. Easy to use and lasts a really long time.

This eyeliner is ok... it's difficult to draw a black line that's actually black. The formula seems to be too thin so it goes on thin and too unsaturated. The color across my eye is uneven, black in some places and gray in others, like watercolor might be across the page. I'm not looking for watercolor, but rather ink. I'm still looking for a "natural" dupe to the Lancome artliner. I may have to go back to that product as no natural product seems to measure up.

As a brunette, I really wanted this to be my new "every day" eyeliner, especially after reading Emma Watson's Into the Gloss article, where she advocates for this eyeliner above all others. The brush is amazingly thin, and the brown color is beautiful, but the actual eyeliner doesn't lie in an even layer across the brush head- I found that it went on my eyelid in a very faint line, and I had to go over it multiple times in order to get a decent depth of color. The eyeliner also goes on very wet, and is heavy on your lid as it dries. Most importantly though, this eyeliner didn't last an entire workday on my eyes: It flaked and cracked very quickly, and by the end of the day it looked as though most of my wing had rubbed off. I unfortunately had to return it for this reason.

I used to wear eyeliner ALL THE TIME- then stopped because eye products started to really irritate my eyes. I found that it just was not worth it so i stopped. I tried to find an eyeliner but after many failed attempts i found this! I have been able to go back to wearing my loved winged eyeliner! SO many compliments too! I think some people so better with felted tips than brushes and so it might take some time to get the hang of but it is very pigmented! I never have to touch up.

This eyeliner does exactly as described. Application is a very easy process and the very thin brush helps to create the exact look you're going for. Sometimes it can be a bit thin and not cover solidly, but I give it 30 seconds to dry before reapplying and that does the trick. On particularly busy days that may include going to the gym, I have noticed a but of flaking, but it's after almost 12 hours of wear. Especially considering the lack of chemicals, it's super worth it.

Love this eyeliner. The color is a rich black. The brush is the perfect size, not too thin. It stays on all day. Would definitely recommend.

This eyeliner has the thinnest brush I have found in a liquid eyeliner. Moreover, this eyeliner doesn't have parabens. It's the only one I will use.

I am completely in love with my new eyeliner by jane iredale, I bought it because I am trying to buy makeup that is cruelty-free and eco-friendly, and it is better than so many other eyeliners that I have tried before. There is such a great pigment to this eyeliner. I will continue to buy forever and I will be trying the brown eyeliner as well!!!

Easy to apply liquid liner that lasts all day. Contains no harsh irritating ingredients. Color stays true and doesn't run or fade.