I loved this eyeliner at first. It goes on so smooth and looks super nice when you put it on! But by the end of the day it is all smudgy and I had black all over my eyelids…

Jane Iredale must have improved their packaging for Mystikol; the applicator now closes securely. The product itself goes on smoothly and is easy to apply; this is a nice neutral bronze-y color and Amethyst is also pretty.

I thought this looked like an easier way to put on eyeliner based on the description and other reviews I read before purchasing. I’ve been pretty disappointed by how much I have to keep going over the product before I actually start to see any color. Once I’ve applied many layers, it does look good, but the application takes way too long. 

I stopped using eyeliner when my eyelids started showing signs of aging; no matter what I did, I couldn't achieve a solid line - my liner would just skip across the lids. This product is really pretty amazing. I can achieve a solid black line - thick or thin - without even trying. It's honestly the easiest eyeliner I have ever used. I haven't had any issues with smudging or fading but I do use a good eyelid primer and it stays put. Highly recommend.

I have never used a product quite like this and have found the brush to work great! The way the brush gets stored in lid is well-designed. It applies smoothly and evenly in terms of pigment as well. I also kind of like that it seems easier to remove than regular eye liner. 

I am definitely not a make up person, but I like to put on eyeliner and mascara. Eyeliners is something that I can never get right. This right here, I love it. it goes on smoothly, doesn't look chunky or splotchy and I feel like I'm doing it right. Definitely a must ALWAYS have for me.

I used to use black eyeshadow with a brush as it didn't smudge but this is even better and very highly pigmented with easy application.

I'm typically very, very bad at applying eyeliners, so I rarely try new products. I accidentally noticed this eyeliner and got interested because of the "powdered" texture. I'm so glad I tried it! Applying is very easy, the texture is smooth, nice and durable. I'm thinking of getting another shades as well.

So easy to use! Color goes on smoothly and stays put all day. Love it! Have purchased this product twice.

This is very convenient and a great product. I will throw all of my other ones away.