This pencil is very nice, it goes on light but you can build upon application. I think if you are looking for a clean eyebrow pencil this is a good one. Many of the reviewers note the pencil breaks easily, which I found to be true. I find if you use the pencil a little at a time it prevents breaking.

This is a nice brow pencil and the color is great for warmer tones, hair with red pigment. It blends well, but I found it to wear off pretty quickly in humid weather.

I've searched far and wide for a perfect pencil and this is the one. The color matches my own hair perfectly and the pencil stays put throughout the day. I hope they never stop making this!

This is a great eyebrow pencil that applies smoothly, precisely and is NOT DRYING. The color blonde compliments my light to medium skin tone and highlighted light brown hair; the color seems more brunette than blonde to me. I sometimes wish Jane Iredale offered a lighter version of her eyebrow pencil so that I could use both the current blonde color and the lighter one. I am never without this pencil...it's been repurchased numerous times and there are two extras in my draw right now.

I am very picky about my makeup looking natural and not caked. Eyebrows can be very tricky and I’ve not had much luck finding good products. This seems to work very well and is easy to apply. My only complaint is it’s so thin it breaks easy and gets wasted.

I use Jane Iredale Brow pencil every day and always have two extras on hand. The formula goes on smoothly, stays put and is not dry. The pencil width is perfect for lash strokes.  I use the color blonde and am a light brunette with highlights. In addition to the brow pencil, I use Jane Iredale GreatShape Eyebrow powder in ash blonde to fill in.  Great products!  

This pencil really works for me. I have very light colored thin eyebrows .  It makes it easy to apply fine lines for a natural look. The brunette is a little dark for my red hair so I use a light touch which is fine for me.  Blonde is too taupe.

I don’t like this brow pencil at all.  I find the consistency difficult to use and the color not great for blondes.  Had high expectations but very disappointed.   😞

Color lasts for 24 hours, easy to apply and very thin tip for precision. This is a pretty minor thing that doesn't impact the product, but I like that the cap for the spoolie end and the pencil end are different colors so I'm not constantly accidentally putting them on the wrong sides.

I LOVE this product. I have blonde eyebrows that are so light in some areas that they look patchy. I use Ash Blonde and this product fills in my brows beautifully and they look SO natural! I like to get a boy-brow look in combination with a brow gel. My brows have never looked better, and I love that this formula is so much cleaner than competitors. My only complaint is that there's so little product in the pencil, it only lasts me two months usually. Still worth it.