I wanted this to line my tightline with - I also wanted to try it as a liner that I could potentially smoke out. I like the color, but it is very difficult to blend IMO; thus, it doesn't really work for me as a smoked out liner - maybe the applicator is too precise? However, it's very good for lining the tightline and very pigmented - a little goes a long way, so I anticipate having this liner for a long time.

Easy to use, smooth and good color on top of my smudge liner. I'll buy it again and in other shades.

Gives bold color and is easy to apply, even on the waterline. My main gripe is that every pencil I have owned breaks and wastes product. I loved the formula so I kept purchasing for a while despite this issue, however I have since made the switch to a different brand.

I absolutely loved this eyeliner while I was able to use it, but after not many uses the tip broke off into the cap and I can't use it at all anymore. I am frustrated at paying this price for an eyeliner that can only be used a few uses, but it was great while it lasted.

It smears easily and breaks easily compared to other liners . And it's NOT water proof on the waterline. Maybe will work for others but it did not for me.

Love this liner! so smooth to put on and doesn't smear or smudge! Built in sharpener makes this always ready and perfectly sharp.

This eyeliner is really the best. I've been through many other brands and Smashbox's Always Sharp gives a crisp line every time and really is water/sweat proof. The pigment is dark and gives the look of a liquid liner with more precision and control...and it stays where you put it. I have turned so many people onto this liner it's crazy.

Fantastic product. Love how I can wear it all day in never smudges. Absolutely love it!