Rewards members get DOUBLE points on SkinCeuticals. Plus, receive a gift when you spend $150+ on the brand. SHOP NOW

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner (0.016 fl. oz.)

Customer Reviews

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner (0.016 fl. oz.) Customer Reviews

USD 22.0
from $22.00
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner (0.016 fl. oz.)
Overall Rating : 4.81 / 5 (151 Reviews)
  • 130 5 star reviews
  • 15 4 star reviews
  • 5 3 star reviews
  • 0 2 star reviews
  • 1 1 star reviews
4.81 / 5 (151 Reviews)
  • 130 5 star reviews
  • 15 4 star reviews
  • 5 3 star reviews
  • 0 2 star reviews
  • 1 1 star reviews

Where reviews refer to beauty products or supplements, results may vary from person to person. Customer reviews are independent and do not represent the views of Dermstore.

Reward members earn 50 points for every review written on verified purchases.

Best eyeliner

5

This is my all time favorite eyeliner that I have used to this day. It's extremely waterproof and lasts ALL DAY for me no matter what I am doing.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

My go to daily eyeliner

5

I've been using this liner for 5+ years now and have gone through 20+ because it's my go-to everyday liner. The formula is smooth and looks beautiful on. The pen tip is fine and easy to maneuver. Reasonable cost. what's not to like?

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Alloy shade is lighter than it appears in the product photo

4

I've used the Stila eyeliner for a long time in the "Intense Black" shade and like it very much. I don't find it to be bulletproof, though - if you forget yourself and rub your eyes this will come off and I find that I do need to touch up throughout the day. HOWEVER I've decided that I like the product and the application enough that it doesn't dissuade me from being a return customer, though :) I wanted to try the Alloy shade to achieve a slightly less bold day-to-day look and found that the photo on Dermstore shows Alloy as being darker than it is in person. (I foolishly relied on the photo alone before purchasing, but if you read the item description carefully, the site does give accurate information that I missed: "Alloy is a rich steel-charcoal shade.") I'd say that in person, Alloy a true medium gray. If that's what you're searching for then this is your color!! But because I was looking for a darker gray, I think I'll be exchanging for the Dark Labradorite.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Stila liquid liner dark brown

5

Absolute favorite liquid liner i have watery eyes and it stays on ALL day without streaking or smudging, very easy to draw a even line, very liquidy formula comes out the pen easily.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Still on the fence on this one...

3

I like the color (a nice dark brown) and the ease of the felt tip of the eyeliner pen but it doesn't go on smoothly as other brands. It does seem to last pretty well without smudging. Not 100 percent sure yet that I'd repurchase.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Good, felt tip isn't my favorite

4

Lasts a good amount of time. But the felt tip just isn't my favorite. Brush tips are easier to wing out, in my opinion. And the tip does get a little ragged after some months which makes it difficult to get a precise application.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Great liquid liner!

4

I found this to be really easy to apply. It is great at first but after some use the tip dulls making it harder to get fine lining. It stays and doesn't smudge!

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Prefer the black

5

The dark brown isn't as dark as I would like but this formula in general is worth a try

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

95 our of 100?

5

Is this my favorite liner every in all of history? I haven't tried EVERY liner so I can't say. Do I feel like this is going to be in the top 5 ever? Definitely! Long lasting, precise, the dark blue is a nice almost black blue with a twist, the black is solid and rich. Dig it

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Wanted to love it !

5

Have read so many reviews for this product , was looking for a liner that's subtle but will last all day. The tip of this liner is very pliable and great for a cat-eye look on top of your lid but doesn't do so well on your lash line. It's messy and hard to apply directly to upper and lower lash line between the lashes. I prefer a pen tip that's not as flimsy for this application . It's also very dark black . Will reserve this liner for a night out not for everyday use for me.

Was this review helpful to you?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner (0.016 fl. oz.) Customer Reviews

USD 22.0
from $22.00
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner (0.016 fl. oz.)

Quantity

( 0 item in your basket items in your basket )