Mascara seemed dry upon opening.  Product  clumped upon application and those clumps later turned into flakes on my upper and lower eyelids.  I do not recommend this mascara and will never buy it again 

I've tried so many mascaras over the years but I go back to this one each and every time. It doesn't flake, it adds length and volume, and it lasts.

Great brush design that allows for easy layering and lengthening lashes without clumping. The mascara doesn’t smudge and leaves lashes feeling healthy. Definitely one of my favorites!

I got this in a subscription box and was excited to receive it again. It works very well to separate the lashes, but doesn't give super dramatic volume. It's good for a natural look.

really like this mascara, lengthens n curls as it states, better then the mile high one from same brand

But a little heavy. I prefer the gold tube over this one, But it's still not a bad formula. Can be a little clumpy, but not as bad as most others.

I prefer the original mascara in the gold tube. This felt a little gloppy for me.

Definitely buildable and smudge-proof, but it really weighs down my lashes so they point down instead of up when I am on my second coat and up.

I try a lot of mascara and this is currently in my top three. It adds volume and length, dries fairly quickly and doesn't flake or smudge throughout the day. Would recommend.

But Way Too Expensive! It does was it says, including resisting water-I lap swim in this mascara! It goes on well, does lift and bend upwards, builds volume, doesn't clump or flake, but there is very little in the tube for what you pay. Also, I am super sensitive to most mascaras, but not this one. I have used expensive high-end mascara for decades; no drugstore mascara works for me. Again, this is still the best mascara I've ever used. A dream mascara I didn't really think was possible. Wish they'd put more than .32 oz in the tube for $24!